Getting to the point
In fact, what it’s all about – and what I appear to miss at every turn
What do you mean?
It’s time for an apology, and the apology is this: I often assume a lot of knowledge, which I have garnered over nearly 30 years. If there ever was a point, it’s this. Rule 1: aim at magnificence. Rule 2: avoid pointless distractions.
The simplest way to explain this is that I want a button to do the things I need to do. When I’m practising, my personal advantage is that I’ve spent a long time working both as an audio engineer and musician, and also trying to solve problems in a myriad of different application spaces. However, because this can get very, very dense, I skip over important parts, because I now see a lot of what I used to think was essential as spurious.
It constantly frustrates me that people are obsessed with IP addresses, MAC addresses, subnets – all of those things that make people think they’re clever network engineers. To be a genuinely good network engineer, you have to understand what the system is doing, not what the components are doing. From a top-down perspective, a network connects an application to another application: basically, the thing above layer 7 to another thing above layer 7.
My constant battle has been dealing with the constraints of doing real-time audio and video over data networks. In 1997 it was basically impossible. In 2026 it’s actually relatively easy – but it has taken that long to evolve.
These days, honestly, I couldn’t care less about IP addresses. I really couldn’t. Subnets? I use IPv6; it’s not a problem. I was talking to a colleague this afternoon, explaining the sheer size of an IPv6 subnet – a single one gives every living person on the planet about 2 billion addresses each – and then I stopped and said: except in your case, you may need to worry, because you have so many gadgets that you’re constantly tripping over them. Maybe you need more. Maybe you’re the exception.
However, it doesn’t matter: the routing is automatic, because everything is end-to-end routed. And this is the point that everybody misses. The Internet was always supposed to be end-to-end routed, and with IPv6 it’s back there now. So stop worrying about IPv4 and all of that stuff you spent days learning. Indeed, I spent years learning this stuff. It’s not wasted – it’s useful to know – but park it, and carry on with Rule 1. To be clear, that doesn’t mean no design: someone still plans the prefixes and, more than ever, the firewall policy – end-to-end reachable doesn’t mean open to all. It means the address stops being something users, and most of us, have to handle.
Scarcity and abundance
In many ways, the IPv4 and IPv6 debate is a microcosm of the two major ways of approaching human existence: scarcity and abundance. What do I know? I know how little I know. The only thing I know is that we all have a finite amount of time, and spending our time striving against scarcity to achieve magnificence is extremely challenging. Our time is better spent embracing abundance – and that is the IPv6 perspective.
Now, I’m not a fool. I know full well that there is no possibility of us exhausting IPv6 as an address space, because quite frankly there is not enough sand on the planet to make that number of chips. That’s the abundance perspective: have more than can ever be used, and get along with doing what’s important.
The scarcity perspective, however, is where we have people who wish to add value through scarcity. We ran out of IPv4 addresses a long time ago. Our time is better spent embracing the near-impossible abundance of IPv6, and just getting on with doing something useful.
For me, useful means a shared emotional experience in a large space. More precisely, I really, really enjoy watching a crowd’s reactions to tiny things I do to an audio path. That’s where I get my greatest pleasure: I change the balance of a mix and the audience starts dancing – whether it be level or time alignment, and I’ve had both experiences on magnificent scales. That’s the point. It’s about giving to others and not expecting false value. Hold all the rentierism of people who see value in the scarcity of IPv4 up against the mirror of IPv6’s abundance, and just make things work. That’s where magnificence comes from.
However, this is not an easy path. In commercial terms, abundance is hard to profit from: to develop, one has to come up with another idea. Heretofore I’ve been fortunate in having many, many ideas – most of them incredibly bad, some quite good, some with impact. However, it is possible. Letting the imagination evaluate potential and build something wonderful is all we can really achieve in our short time on the planet.